Vic Premier Ben Carroll haunted by Daniel Andrews at debate

Victorian Premier Ben Carroll’s version of ‘he who must not be named’ only succeeded in conjuring the dark spectre of his predecessors in Mark Knight’s cartoon of the state leaders’ debate

Victorian Premier Ben Carroll had a Voldemort-style encounter in Mark Knight's cartoon take on the election candidates' Leaders' Debate this week. Picture: Mark Knight
Victorian Premier Ben Carroll had a Voldemort-style encounter in Mark Knight's cartoon take on the election candidates' Leaders' Debate this week. Picture: Mark Knight

READING LEVEL: ORANGE

We are two weeks out from election day in Victoria and this week it was the Leaders’ Debate. Ho hum, I hear you yawn. And yes: it is usually the leaders of the two main parties, Labor and Liberal, squaring off against each other in a “he said, she said” punch on – but politics has changed.

Such is the contempt* in the electorate for the two main political parties that we see minor parties and independents becoming more popular and even contenders* for power.

The rise of Pauline Hanson’s One Nation Party, the Greens, the Teals (even though they say they’re not a party!) and other independents are now taking ground once held by Labor and the Liberal and the Nationals, known as the Coalition.

Former Victorian Labor premiers Dan Andrews and Jacinta Allan were missing from the official launch of Ben Carroll's election campaign. Picture: composite/NewsWire
Former Victorian Labor premiers Dan Andrews and Jacinta Allan were missing from the official launch of Ben Carroll's election campaign. Picture: composite/NewsWire

In Victoria, the Labor Party has been in power for 12 years, first with Daniel Andrews as premier, then when he resigned in 2023, his deputy Jacinta Allan took over until this year, when her opinion polls became so dire and she was up to her neck in Victoria’s Big Build infrastructure* crisis that she resigned and her deputy Ben Carroll became top dog.

The first words that came out his mouth when he became Premier Carroll were, “I’m not Dan Andrews or Jacinta Allan”! And that is how Ben Carroll has run his campaign, desperately trying to distance himself from his two predecessors*, who had become electoral liabilities* for a state government seeking a fourth term in office.

Jess Wilson ventured to Gippsland, while Premier Ben Carroll visited Bendigo on the election trail. Pictures: composite/Josie Hayden/Tony Gough
Jess Wilson ventured to Gippsland, while Premier Ben Carroll visited Bendigo on the election trail. Pictures: composite/Josie Hayden/Tony Gough

So if voters were leaving Labor, where would they go? One Nation? The Greens? For many years, the Victorian Liberals in Opposition had become a disorganised, self-obsessed, inward looking rabble*, unable to take the fight up to Dan Andrews or offer themselves up as an alternative government. As a result, Labor won three elections, increasing their majorities at each election.

One Nation Victoria held a campaign launch event for the Western Metropolitan Region at St Albans with Pauline Hanson on hand to speak to supporters. Picture: Jake Nowakowski
One Nation Victoria held a campaign launch event for the Western Metropolitan Region at St Albans with Pauline Hanson on hand to speak to supporters. Picture: Jake Nowakowski

Then a young, fresh-faced, first term Liberal politician Jess Wilson took on the Liberal leadership last year and no one gave her much of a chance against the tough Labor mobsters*. But she hung in, and as the cost of living got tougher on people, Victoria’s state debt approached $200 billion, pothole-infested roads destroyed cars, machetes became the weapon of choice, tax rises, hospitals and police budgets squeezed and the Big Build Royal Commission revealed how we lost $15 billion plus of taxpayers’ money via the CFMEU* and their outlaw bikie union delegates, hey, the Liberals didn’t look so bad compared to Labor!

Opposition Leader Jess Wilson also bought souvlakis for the media following her on the campaign trail. Picture: NewsWire/ Josie Hayden
Opposition Leader Jess Wilson also bought souvlakis for the media following her on the campaign trail. Picture: NewsWire/ Josie Hayden

One Nation has increased its popularity with voters, both federally and in Victoria, for the same reasons: voters are unhappy with the Albanese Government in a cost of living crisis. The Greens picked up former Labor voters from the left as well. It seemed like the Victorian election would be a tsunami-like wipe-out for the Labor Party but you can never be sure with our preferential voting system and the distribution of preferences.

Victorian potholes have become notorious as symbolic of the chaotic condition of the state’s politics. Whatever the state Labor government has been spending tax payers’ money on, it seems not to have been roads.
Victorian potholes have become notorious as symbolic of the chaotic condition of the state’s politics. Whatever the state Labor government has been spending tax payers’ money on, it seems not to have been roads.

So when the Leaders’ Debate was set for this week, it was not just the Labor and Liberal leaders, but the Greens leader Ellen Sandell and the Victorian leader of One Nation, Warren Pickering. The four leaders faced tough questions from an audience of random voters. Bring it on!

My cartoon would be about the debate and I watched the politicians eagerly, listening to their replies. These four are all relatively new to their leadership roles and therefore I haven’t drawn them so much. The debate was an opportunity for me to watch their body language, a chance to gauge what they looked like under pressure and to improve my caricatures* of them.

Victorian One Nation leader Warren Pickering speaks at the Melbourne Press Club. Picture: NewsWire/Andrew Henshaw
Victorian One Nation leader Warren Pickering speaks at the Melbourne Press Club. Picture: NewsWire/Andrew Henshaw

During the debate, it was noticed that Ben Carroll would not refer to Dan Andrews or Jacinta Allan by name, so poisonous might they prove to be to his campaign. It was like something from Harry Potter, with Premier Carroll playing a “he who must not be named” game. Jess Wilson jumped on it, referring to the Voldemort* character in the famous wizard novel series, whom no one dares mention. That was all I needed to get the wheels turning to create a cartoon on the debate.

Will voters buy Opposition Leader Jess Wilson’s “can do” pitch at appearance including this one at RubberTough Industries? Victoria heads to the polls in two weeks. Picture: NewsWire/Josie Hayden
Will voters buy Opposition Leader Jess Wilson’s “can do” pitch at appearance including this one at RubberTough Industries? Victoria heads to the polls in two weeks. Picture: NewsWire/Josie Hayden

I decided to draw all four of our leaders standing at their lecterns, but one of them, Ben Carroll, would have the lurking presence of “he who must not be mentioned during the Victorian election campaign”: former premier Daniel Andrews, looming right behind him. I drew Dan in Voldemort guise: the bluish hue, piercing eyes, dark robe and long fingernails hovering over Carroll. He is whispering in the Premier’s ear to say his name. Will Ben Carroll do it?

Actor Ralph Fiennes as Voldemort in a scene from film Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1. Picture: file image
Actor Ralph Fiennes as Voldemort in a scene from film Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1. Picture: file image

Instead, I had Carroll falling back on a reply that a CFMEU bikie was using while being cross-examined at the Big Build Royal Commission that very day: “I don’t recall”.

It has become the default answer to avoid answering the tough questions at the Royal Commission. I thought Ben Carroll might need to use it here.

By deliberately not mentioning Daniel Andrews’ name, Premier Carroll only drew more attention to his former leader than might have otherwise been the case.

“I can’t recall”: three words used with disturbing frequency at the Big Build Royal Commission. Picture: Mark Knight
“I can’t recall”: three words used with disturbing frequency at the Big Build Royal Commission. Picture: Mark Knight

POLL

GLOSSARY

  • contempt: a strong feeling of disliking and having no respect for someone or something
  • contenders: people who compete with other people to try to win something
  • infrastructure: the basic systems and services, such as transport and power supplies, that a country or organisation uses in order to work effectively
  • predecessors: someone who had a job or a position before someone else, or something that comes before another thing in time or in a series
  • liabilities: negative people or things that stand in your way or weigh you down
  • rabble: a large, noisy, uncontrolled group of people
  • mobsters: gangsters, organised group of criminals
  • CFMEU: the Construction, Forestry and Maritime Employees Union
  • caricature: a drawing or a written or spoken description that makes part of someone’s appearance or character more noticeable than it really is, or the skill of doing this
  • Voldemort: the evil wizard lord in Harry Potter, the name was apparently coined by the series’ author J. K. Rowling from the French “vol de mort”, meaning a flight or death from death

EXTRA READING

Runaway train halted, or is it?

Will Vic hear Hanson’s siren song?

Labor’s Ben Carroll gets top job in Victoria

QUICK QUIZ

  1. Which Victorian politicians took part in the Leaders’ Debate?
  2. Victoria’s state debt is approaching what astronomical sum?
  3. What are some of the key issues in Victoria that Mark identifies as driving voter dissatisfaction?
  4. Which party has increased its voter support both in Victoria and federally?
  5. Which former Victorian premier did Mark depict as Harry Potter’s nemesis Voldemort?

LISTEN TO THIS STORY

CLASSROOM ACTIVITIES
1. Cartoon analysis
After reading and analysing the Mark Knight cartoon in the Kids News article, answer the following questions to help you get the full meaning out of his drawing:

  • What is the main issue Mark Knight is highlighting?
  • Who is portrayed in the cartoon?
  • How are they portrayed?
  • What is the humour in the drawing?
  • Who might agree with his viewpoint?
  • Who might disagree or possibly be offended by this viewpoint?
  • Do you think he makes a good point? Explain your answer.

Time: allow 25 minutes to complete this activity
Curriculum Links: English, Personal and Social, Critical and Creative Thinking

2. Extension
Write a response to this cartoon from the viewpoint of one of the people or objects portrayed in the cartoon. Think, what would be their response to the speech bubble and satire from the cartoon.

Write or draw your response below.

Time: allow 15 minutes to complete this activity
Curriculum Links: English, Visual Arts, Personal and Social, Critical and Creative Thinking

VCOP ACTIVITY
Stretch your sentence
Find a “who” in the cartoon – a person or an animal. Write it down.

Add three adjectives to describe them better.

Now add a verb to your list. What are they doing?

Add an adverb about how they are doing the action.

Using all the words listed, create one descriptive sentence.